Where did all the money go? It's in the Black Box...: As revenues from music become increasingly diversified, it's becoming more and more difficult for artists to keep track of what they're owed
"If you are going up against a giant, it helps if you too are a giant. And scrappy.
6/17/08
Music News Bulletin - 17/06/08
6/10/08
How can CEOs drive accountability and outcome measurement in their charities without losing sight of organisations caring supporting function?
Developing effective monitoring to improve leadership and public perceptions
The third sector’s goals are more intangible and their ability to evaluate success less clear cut than the private sector, which focuses on profitability; or the public sector, where accountability comes through elected politicians. These differences in intension and preferred measurements have often caused problems, as funding agreements have usually been focused on inputs (where money went) and outputs (what the charity did), rather than outcomes (what difference was made).
Currently, the monitoring system of third sector organisations are largely controlled by funders, often stipulating reporting which offers minimal benefit to the third sector. Consequentially organisations spend too much time and resources focusing on providing less appropriate information. This reduces funders’ ability to fully understand the fund’s benefits, as they may receive reports that don’t fully reflect how much of an impact their money is making to communities.
However, more considered and proactive outcome measurements would reassure funders, and focus organisations minds on the provision of services. If third sector organisations were better able to highlight their societal benefits through effective performance measurement systems, whilst showing financial prudence then they would be more attractive to funders, and increase their role on the delivery of public services.
Learning to communicate more effectively with funders
New Philanthropy Capital (NPC) highlights a reciprocal problem between funders and the third sector, with funders being mistrustful of the third sector’s financial competence, and recipients being too nervous to question the funders volume or choice of reporting. However, through examining the optimum level of measurement, and having the confidence to explain the benefits of differing approaches it is possible to build trust with funders, provide them information that highlights the positive outcomes from their investment, and reduce administrative waste.
When funders ask for detailed reports they want to ensure that their money is not being wasted. However, often too little feedback is given, leaving charities unaware of how their reports are being used, or even at all. This can be demoralising, time consuming and inhibits future improvements to the monitoring system.
This is exacerbated by the timidity of some organisations in the face of funders, as they are reluctant to question or challenge their demands for fear of alienating funders. This weakens relationships and threatens trust, as charities may be hesitant to report problems or speak clearly.
NPC’s ‘Turning the Tables’ pilot study encouraged charities to be more proactive through producing their own standard report and then offering it to all of their funders. They suggested creating three types of reports:
- A core report, containing information relevant to the whole organisation.
- Project reports, containing detailed project specific information.
- Individual reports, tailored to the needs of particular funders.
This method helped re-examine the reporting structure through taking a holistic approach; improving organisations’ relationships with funders, through increasing empathy; and lowering administrative costs through reduced duplication and targeted monitoring.
Ensuring that staff members and service users are involved in the monitoring process
Engaging with staff is a useful way of encouraging innovation and ingenuity to create solutions. Given the fact that staff members are the front line of service it is necessary to seek their input to create an optimum balance between improving the needs of service users and funders’ needs for accountability and financial competence. Ensuring support for change and ascertaining whether the organisation currently has the training and capacity to handle any governance reforms is critical.
Similarly the involvement of service users in the governance of organisations and in defining outcomes is one of the factors which helps to distinguish the third sector as having a user-centred perspective, as opposed to the organisation-centred perspective so often seen in the public sector. Focusing public services on the user is one of the most fundamental challenges facing organisations who delivery and commission public services and is a key strength for the third sector.
Far from compromising the support which third sector organisations provide, a greater emphasis on outcomes and performance measurement will mean that organisations focus on delivering the services which really matter, and that funders are aware of the real impact which they are making.
This article was written by Jonathan McHugh in June 2008
6/4/08
EU Public Affairs Monitor - 04/06/08
YouTomb: A YouTube takedown
6/1/08
Adam Smith Notes
Smith’s most quoted passage by laissez faire economists is his reasoning that the butcher, brewer and baker only exist in those professions to serve their own needs rather than others. This is an important piece and is useful in reemphasising the intension of business, the return of profit. However, this viewpoint is too narrow, as it is followed by Smith stressing that “civilised society [man] stands at all times in need of the cooperation and assistance of great multitudes, while his whole life is scarcely sufficient to gain the friendship of a few persons.”
Because mutual sympathy is itself pleasurable, it “enlivens joy by presenting another source of satisfaction; and it alleviates grief. It enlivens job by presenting another source of satisfaction; and it alleviates grief by insinuating inot the heart almost the only agreeable sensation which it is at that time capable of receiving.” Adam Smith
This omittance of Smith’s moralising is a hollowing of the laissez faire belief, as it fails to recognise the benefits of mutual support and leaves the ideology free to abuse by people keen to justify selfishness. It is perhaps this abandoning of Smith’s moralistic dimension by his successors that Skidenski describes the invisible hand as paralysed.
Similarly, although Smith recognised and accepted that the market system would go through periods of growth and decline, he held sympathies towards bankruptcy, unlike today’s practitioners who consider it an acceptable method of rooting out the weak.
Rosenburg found that it would be unthinkable for a moral philosopher like Adam Smith to abandon the ideas contained in the Theory of Moral Sentiments in 1759 when he published the Wealth of Nations in 1776 without making it explicitly clear.
Smith was searching for an institutional framework which would eliminate zero sum gains, ways in which wealth may be pursued without contributing to the welfare of society. Therefore, Smith’s vision was not the open free for all that contemporary economists may suggest but as Rosenburg puts it “a careful balancing of incentive, of provision of opportunity to enlarge ones income against the opportunities for abuse.”
Smith highlighted that self interest can be pursued in a number off undesirable ways as self interest will only serve the public interest when the right institutional arrangements create the right psychic tension to direct such self interest The direction of effort is as important as its intensity.
“Society…cannot subsist among those who are at times ready to hurt and injure one another.” Adam Smith
The attainment and possession of wealth are regarded by Smith as almost universally corrupting. For once such wealth has been acquired, man naturally gives vent to his desire for ease, “the indulgence an variety of the rich” is fully as important a force in Smith’s system as is the desire for riches itself.
“The high rate of profit seems every where to destroy that parsimony which in other circumstances is natural to the character of the merchant. When profits are high, that sober virtue seems superfluous, and an expensive luxury to suit better the affluence of his situation.” Adam Smith
A central, unifying theme in Smith’s Wealth of Nations is his critique of human institutions on the basis of whether or not they are so contrived as to frustrate mans baser impulses (“natural insolvence”) and antisocial prodivities and to make possible the pursuit of self interest only in a socially beneficial fashion. Hence his criticism of mercantilism, which strengthened merchants to better themselves without contributing to the nation’s economic welfare.
These notes were collected in June 2008
5/30/08
US Public Affairs - 30/05/09
Lessig on the orphan works bill
EU Commission: Internal Market - 30/05/08
"The European Commission wants practical, pragmatic suggestions for fighting the “modern-day highway robbery” known as piracy and counterfeiting, Internal Market Commissioner Charlie McCreevy said at a 13 May commission-sponsored high level conference on the issues.
McCreevy stressed that more regulation is not the answer, and that solutions lie with public-private cooperation. He called on industry to lead the battle against fakes, and on internet service providers (ISPs) to solve the problem of illegal downloads. But he also outlined planned expansion of anti-counterfeiting and anti-piracy efforts within the Commission." [IPWatch]
European Commission Proposes Forum On Future Of Copying Levies
"The European Commission has recommended that a forum involving creative artists and the consumer industry should be established to determine the future of private copying levies.
Twenty-one of the European Union’s 27 countries impose oft-criticised surcharges on equipment - ranging from blank cassettes to MP3 players and mobile phones - that may be used for recording or copying images or sound. While such levies are officially designed to compensate musicians or authors for the use of their work, they have attracted much criticism for allegedly being imposed in an arbitrary manner and for hampering cross-border trade within the EU." [IPWatch]
EU Public Affairs Monitor - 30/05/08
"Three Strikes and You're Out" Policy Strikes Out
"The new baseball season is in full swing, yet in recent months the phrase "three strikes and you’re out" has taken on an entirely different meaning on the Internet. My new technology law column (Toronto Star version, homepage version) reports on how, prodded by content lobby groups, a handful of governments have moved toward requiring Internet service providers to terminate subscribers if they engage in file sharing activities on three occasions. The policy - occasionally referred to as "graduated response" - received support last fall from French President Nicolas Sarkozy, who pressured the private sector to negotiate an agreement to implement the three strikes system. The policy soon attracted global attention as the
"A German court has ruled that the identities of ISP subscribers should not be disclosed as part of potential file-sharing copyright investigations, finding that such measures can only be used for "heavy" crimes like terrorism, murder or child pornography, TorrentFreak reports. The
"The
5/9/08
EU Commission: Information and Society 05/09/08
The Commission today called on the Parliament and Council to support a new drive to cut red tape and allow greater flexibility to make European high-tech research more effective. It was responding to the 'Aho report', the most comprehensive evaluation of EU ICT research yet, looking beyond the management of research to evaluate its impact on innovation. The report highlighted that EU research could be of greater benefit for European competitiveness by involving and supporting high growth companies and providing better links between research and venture capital. The Commission, which has launched several initiatives to involve leading companies in research (IP/08/910, IP/08/824, IP/08/785), is committed to making the information and communications technology (ICT) research it supports more effective in terms of delivering business opportunities. It is also launching a public consultation that will feed into proposals to this end in early 2009. [Europa]
Opening soon: a digital library for Europe 11/08/08
Europe's cultural diversity in books, music, paintings, photographs, and films open to all citizens at the click of a mouse via one portal – this dream of a European Digital Library could become reality this autumn. However, further efforts by the EU Member States are needed, said the Commission today in a new Communication on making available digital versions of works from cultural institutions all over Europe. Digitisation of cultural works can give Europeans access to material from museums, libraries and archives abroad without having to travel or turn hundreds of pages to find a piece of information. Europe's libraries alone contain more than 2.5 billion books, but only about 1% of archival material is available in digital form. The Commission therefore called on Member States to do more to make digitised works available online for Europeans to browse them digitally, for study, work or leisure. The Commission itself will provide some € 120 million in 2009-2010 for improving online access to Europe's cultural heritage. [Europa]
Supporting social tourism 21/08/08
The Tourism Unit of the European Commission’s Enterprise and Industry DG is promoting the exchange of good practice on social tourism through a series of conferences and workshops, launched in 2006, as part of the Commission’s drive to promote tourism in the context of the Lisbon strategy. The most recent, in Brussels in April 2008, was on the topic ‘Facilitating the growth of the youth and senior citizen tourism markets’. In addition to various actions supported by the Commission, good practices in tourism by local authorities and private sector from several parts of Europe were also reviewed. [Europa]
EU Commission Enterprise and Industry Monitor - 05/09/08
The Best Idea for Red Tape Reduction Award aims at identifying innovative suggestions for reducing unnecessary bureaucracy stemming from European law. Cutting red tape will allow companies to spend more time on their core activities and free up resources for research, innovation and growth. The purpose of the competition is to generate ideas for the European Commission to consider as part of its Action Programme for Reducing Administrative Burdens. [Europa]
4/22/08
Music News Bulletin - 22/04/08
Seems like I'm the only person who thought Sony BMG's download cards were a good idea. Little plastic cards that are redeemable for music downloads? At least one other person likes the idea. On its blog, Phonelopie, Toronto Montreal indie record store Phonopolis encourages labels to sell download codes -- not cards, but codes -- and offers a rough sketch of how it could work. [Coolfer]
BusinessWeek on Other Music and New Strategies 21/04/08
BusinessWeek.com has an article on brick-and-mortar retail's adjustment to falling CD sales. New York City's Other Music is a centerpiece of the article.
Filter through the requisite industry statistics and analyst quotes and you get to a few interesting things. First, the article claims its download store now account for a quarter of all Other Music sales. Second, Other Music hopes to have sponsors underwrite the in-store performances it records and streams from its website. [Coolfer]
What last.fm's sales increase means to me 10/04/08
Last.fm issued a press release saying its "free music boosts CD and download sales"...which makes you wonder how bad CD sales would be without all those free streaming services.
Yes, free music looks to improve music purchases, but be careful how you word the claim. Just being free won't do it. It's the type of free service that matters. (You have to dig into the press release to see co-founder Martin Stiksel relate the type of service to the sales.) [Coolfer]
The Race For The Silver 26/03/08
A good post over at Alley Insider pointed me to a USA Today article about the battle for bragging rights as runner-up to iTunes in digital music sales. Amazon.com says it is number two. eMusic says it is number two. The USA Today reporter called up four majors -- who have no relationship with eMusic outside of equity ownership of some indies -- and they all said Amazon.com. [Coolfer]
TVT's Bankruptcy A Warning For Chart-Driven Indies 21/02/08
Word broke the other day that TVT filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy protection. It may have surprised some people. After all, indies are taking away market share from the majors, right? They're enjoying the benefits of digital distribution. They don't have a reputation for high-salaries executives. [Coolfer]
Sony BMG Debuts MP3 Gift Cards 07/01/08
On the heels of news that it would drop DRM from its downloads, Sony BMG has announced it will sell artist-branded gift cards redeemable for MP3 files. Consumers will redeem cards an initial run of 37 different cards at Musicpass.com. Though its catalog will eventually be available at the proven digital retailers, Sony BMG's move shows a desire to develop its own solution. Not all of the money will not be kept in-house, though, as the cards will be available at 4,500 brick-and-mortar retailers (Best Buy, Target, Fred's, f.y.e., Winn-Dixie) by the end of the month. [Coolfer]
The Economist On Britain's Music Retail 19/01/07
There's a good but brief article at The Economist about Britain's music retail climate. Low-margin supermaket chains which account for ___% of sales, are bringing downward pressure on music-specialty stores. [Coolfer]