Showing posts with label German politics. Show all posts
Showing posts with label German politics. Show all posts

1/16/09

EU Public Affairs Monitor - 16/01/09

Christine Albanel se rend à Cannes pour inaugurer le 43e Marché international de la Musique et de l’Edition Musicale (MIDEM)
"...qui se tient du 17 au 21 janvier. Elle y prononcera un discours, suivi d'une conférence de presse. Elle rencontrera aussi des parlementaires et des professionnels du secteur musical à propos du projet de loi « Création et Internet ».

Le plus grand marché musical au monde. Chaque année, depuis 1967, le MIDEM réunit à Cannes les professionnels du monde entier, qui travaillent dans tous les secteurs de la filière musicale – disque, édition, spectacle vivant, vidéo clip, internet, téléphonie mobile...


Pour son édition 2008, le MIDEM a rassemblé 9 093 participants représentant 4 545 entreprises provenant de 88 pays. Ils ont été 2 233 à tenir un stand. La surface d’exposition était de plus de 9 000 m2.. 482 journalistes appartenant à 398 médias étaient présents pour couvrir l'évènement. L'Origine des participants en 2008: Europe: 67%. Amérique: 22%. Asie: 6%. Océanie: 2%. Moyen-Orient: 2%. Afrique: 1%.
Le 43e Marché international de la Musique et de l’Edition Musicale (MIDEM), qui se tient du 17 au 21 janvier à Cannes. Il est inauguré par Christine Albanel." [Culture]


La coalition d'Angela Merkel s'accorde sur un plan de relance historique
"Les partis de la coalition gouvernementale allemande, CDU et SPD, ont officiellement adopté, lundi soir 12 janvier, un plan de relance historique de 50 milliards d'euros sur deux ans, prévoyant notamment des baisses d'impôts. Il vise à donner un coup de fouet à l'économie de la première puissance exportatrice mondiale menacée d'une grave récession, alors que se profilent les élections législatives du 27 septembre.

Ce plan de relance économique, le plus important dans l'histoire de l'Allemagne d'après-guerre, comprendra des baisses d'impôt d'un montant de quelque 18 milliards d'euros pour les particuliers et pour les entreprises, ont indiqué Peter Struck, chef du groupe parlementaire SPD et Volker Kauder, chef du groupe CDU, à l'issue d'une réunion commune à la chancellerie. Ce plan prévoit également "un grand pacte pour l'investissement" de 17 à 18 milliards d'euros dans lequel seront impliqués l'Etat fédéral, les Etats régionaux et les communes, a souligné M. Struck à l'issue de la réunion de près de six heures dirigée par la chancelière Angela Merkel." [LeMonde]


Sarkozy annonce la gratuité des musées pour les moins de 25 ans
"Lors de ses voeux devant les responsables du monde de la culture, le Président a aussi promis 100 millions d’euros pour la rénovation du patrimoine. Le président Nicolas Sarkozy a annoncé aujourd’hui un accès gratuit aux musées et aux monuments de l’Etat pour les moins de 25 ans ainsi que les professeurs. Cette mesure entrera en vigueur le 4 avril, a précisé le chef de l’Etat, lors de ses voeux devant les responsables du monde de la culture.


Cette mesure de gratuité «ne tue pas les musées, au contraire, car les jeunes qui ont l’habitude d’aller au musée» iront également quand ils seront adultes, a jugé Sarkozy. Le ministère de la Culture avait mené au premier semestre 2008 une expérimentation de gratuité totale (pour les collections permanentes) dans quatorze établissements nationaux, musées ou monuments, avec pour objectif d’élargir leur fréquentation à de nouveaux publics." [Liberation]

11/30/08

US Public Affairs - 30/11/08

In Peer-to-Peer File-Sharing Case, "Distribution" Does Not Mean "Making Available"

"At trial, the plaintiffs sought to prove that the defendant, a single mother in Duluth, had willfully infringed 24 of the plaintiffs' recordings by downloading and distributing them via the peer-to-peer program Kazaa. Finding that the defendant had infringed, the jury awarded the plaintiffs statutory damages of $9,250 per song, for a total of $222,000. The defendant filed a motion for a new trial or, in the alternative, for remittitur, calling for a reduction of excessive damages; the plaintiffs filed an unopposed motion to amend judgment, seeking an injunction. Instead, the court elected sua sponte to address the possibility of granting a new trial because of an incorrect jury instruction." [CyberLaw]


Music Sampling Does Not Infringe on Copyright, But…

"The German Supreme Court (BGH) clarified last week that sampling does not infringe on copyright in the work from which samples were taken for the purpose of creating a new work. There is a catch hiding in the details, though. According to the official press release (in German), the highest judicial authority in Germany ruled that a certain statutory exception principally covered instances of sampling. The relevant exception is anchored in section 24 to the German copyright act, known as “free use” (freie Benutzung). Free use is not fair use, but you can think about it as an extreme version of the transformativeness element familiar from the U.S. fair use analysis. Accordingly, the new work must transform the work of which elements it uses into something independent and wholly different. While using the copyrighted elements taken from the prior work, such use should be so transformative that the first work becomes hardly recognizable as the source." [CyberLaw]


Digital Copyright Issues and the Ubiquitous iPod

"The advent of new technologies has resulted in Copyright law having to adapt to new situations and infringements. These technologies, including music formats that contain compression, as well as the reduction in cost and size of hard drives has created significant new challenges and markets for digital content. Even in the short life of the iPod, it has gone from a music device, to a multimedia device. This article examines some of the issues and case law that is relevant to the content revolution created by the iPod." [SSRN]

The Dangers of the Digital Millennium Copyright Act: Much Ado about Nothing?

"In 1998, Congress passed the Digital Millennium Copyright Act (DMCA), a landmark piece of legislation aimed at protecting copyright holders from those who might manufacture or traffic technology capable of allowing users to evade piracy protections on the underlying work. At its core, the DMCA flatly prohibits the circumvention of technological protection measures in order to gain access to copyrighted works, with no safety valve for any traditionally protected uses. While hailed as a victory by the software and entertainment industries, the academic and scientific communities have been far less enthusiastic. The DMCA's goal of combating piracy is a noble one, but lurking is the danger that it comes at the expense of public access to protected works and future innovation. Despite America's long history of fair use protections in copyright law, many commentators have warned that consumers now find themselves unable to do many of the same things with copyrighted works that they previously could - anyone who might sell them the technology to access a protected work and enable fair use would find themselves in violation of the DMCA. Worse, early litigation dramatically expanded the definition of what constitutes a technological protection measure deserving of the law's respect. As the definition broadened, scholars feared that even modest innovations - ones that would never qualify for patent protection under existing law - could wind up receiving perpetual patent-like protection through the backdoor of the DMCA. Despite the experts' dire predictions, however, subsequent common law interpretation of the DMCA has reigned in many of its potential dangers - the judiciary's focus is rightly on the need to balance innovators' interests with the equally important goals of public access and enhancing overall social welfare. Nonetheless, coherent and uniform protection of fair use under the DMCA is likely best achieved through Congressional action." [SSRN]


Why Emerging Business Models and Not Copyright Law are the Key to Monetising Content Online

"The multimedia Internet is here to stay. Rich media - including videos, music, podcasts, and flash animation - is already a key feature of the Internet experience, and will only grow in diversity and importance. As Internet users increasingly crave - and technology increasingly enables - multimedia content delivered on demand over broadband connections, the number of songs, videos, and other media online will increase exponentially to feed the demand. As online media consumption increases, so will expectations for its capacity to generate revenue for content owners and creators. Analysts boldly predict a bright future for the entertainment industries, especially in Asia, with broadband Internet cited as a key growth driver. Yet, to date, the vast majority of music and video acquired or consumed online is free and uncompensated. Despite the rising expectations for monetizing content on the Web, no clear sustainable, scalable model for monetizing content has emerged that compares to the level of revenues copyright owners have enjoyed in the "physical" (as opposed to online) market." [SSRN]

11/7/08

EU Public Affairs Monitor - 07/11/08

Benchmarks for innovation policy: A new study aims to find the ideal setting for entrepreneurs.
"A study to be published next month will set out an “entrepreneurial idyll” or an ideal environment for entrepreneurs to exist.
The study, carried out by Birmingham University and Cambridge University, aims to step away from the policy-driven measures to help boost small- and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs) and focus instead on what makes firms do well." [EuropeanVoice]

Spat over VAT persists - Germany remains highly critical over plans to lower VAT for more businesses.
"A row about extending the EU's lowest, 5% VAT rate to labour-intensive industries is likely to continue well into December, following a meeting today that revealed that divisions between the EU's 27 finance ministers remain deep.

There was, though, more agreement on VAT on cross-border trade and movement on several other issues, including an agreement to review alleged tax-evasion loopholes for Liechtenstein.
During the Ecofin meeting of finance ministers, Germany made it clear that there is no evidence that lowering VAT for labour-intensive businesses such as restaurants would create jobs and said thorough discussion is still required. The European Commission, with the strong backing of France, the EU presidency, presented the proposal in July." [EuropeanVoice]

French Senate Validates Three-Strike Scheme
"The French Senate has adopted the "Creation and Internet" law, only 24 hours after the debates began. While intense debates were anticipated, the draft gathered 297 votes in favor and only 15 against.

The draft law, which now has to be voted by the French Parliament, suffered surprisingly few amendments by the Senators, who most notably validated the three-strike scheme, under which infringers could ultimately see their Internet access cut." [Billboard][CMUDaily]

9/30/08

In the Loop: 30/09/08

Germans gives peeking Google one in the eye: Schleswig-Holstein's answer is NEIN!
30th September 2008
"The town of Molfsee near Kiel in the north-western German state of Schleswig-Holstein doesn't want to be filmed by Google for its Street View program, a service that provides 360-degrees street level images via Google Maps.

The leader of the Christian Democratic Union on the town council told the Lübecker Nachrichten that "we are not going to let this happen". The 5,000 inhabitants find the project "extremely alarming" as criminals can plan break-ins more easily. Germany's Federal Commissioner for Data Protection also has major misgivings about Google's plans, according to Der Spiegel." [TheRegister]

Sky told to hand over footy and film rights: Rivals to get access at fair price
Posted in Government, 30th September 2008
"The UK's media regulator Ofcom has told Sky it should offer to sell rights to football games and Hollywood films to other broadcasters at a fair price.

The investigation into pay TV was begun after complaints were made by BT, Virgin, Setanta and Top Up TV. Ofcom reckons that consumers make their choices of which service to go with based on content not the features of different platforms. Big films and live Premiership games are a big draw for viewers and Sky has "market power" in these areas." [TheRegister]

Tories would decentralise NHS IT: Want patient confidence and reined-in data 30/09/08
"An incoming Conservative government would decentralise health service computing and extend competition between suppliers, according to a plan released at its party conference.

The party's NHS Improvement Plan, released on 29 September 2008 by shadow health secretary Andrew Lansley, says the party will replace "Labour's centrally determined and unresponsive national IT system."" [TheRegister]

Secret Service camera bought on eBay: Nikon camera, good nick, includes secret files 30th September 2008
"Today's government data loss shenanigan is a repeat performance of that old favourite - flogging off old kit containing secret information to a random punter through online tat bazaar eBay.

An unnamed 28-year-old delivery man from Hemel Hempstead bought a Nikon Coolpix camera for £17 on eBay. But when he returned from his holiday and downloaded the contents of the camera he found pictures of rocket launchers, log-in details for the Secret Service's encrypted remote computer network marked Top Secret and a hand-drawn diagram linking different, named al-Qaeda cells including individual names and occupations." [TheRegister]

US Congress rubberstamps IP enforcement bill: DoJ suits out, White House czar in 29/09/08
The US House of Representatives on Sunday passed a bill heavily backed by the recording industry that would create an intellectual property enforcement czar position in the White House as well as significantly increase penalties for IP infringement.

The bill passed unanimously through the Senate on Friday after being stripped of a controversial provision that would allow the US Department of Justice to file civil suits against suspected copyright violators on behalf of copyright holders. [TheRegister]

Click here to read more information on Mr Grimsdale, King Heron and Mobius

5/30/08

EU Public Affairs Monitor - 30/05/08

"Three Strikes and You're Out" Policy Strikes Out April 21, 2008
"The new baseball season is in full swing, yet in recent months the phrase "three strikes and you’re out" has taken on an entirely different meaning on the Internet. My new technology law column (Toronto Star version, homepage version) reports on how, prodded by content lobby groups, a handful of governments have moved toward requiring Internet service providers to terminate subscribers if they engage in file sharing activities on three occasions. The policy - occasionally referred to as "graduated response" - received support last fall from French President Nicolas Sarkozy, who pressured the private sector to negotiate an agreement to implement the three strikes system. The policy soon attracted global attention as the United Kingdom, Japan, and Australia all announced that they were contemplating a similar approach.

In recent weeks, however, it would appear that governments are beginning to have sober second thoughts. After a Swedish judge recommended adopting the three strikes policy, that country's Ministers of Justice and Culture wrote a public opinion piece setting out their forthcoming policy that explicitly excluded the three strikes model." [MichaelGeist]

German Court Says ISPs Can't ID File-Swappers March 20, 2008
"A German court has ruled that the identities of ISP subscribers should not be disclosed as part of potential file-sharing copyright investigations, finding that such measures can only be used for "heavy" crimes like terrorism, murder or child pornography, TorrentFreak reports. The Federal Constitutional Court's (FCC) ruling will stand for six months, after which time it could be made final.

Earlier this week, Italy's government agency that deals with privacy issues made a similar finding, ruling that companies like Logistep that harvest IP addresses from file-swappers for use in copyright investigations are breaking the law." [DWMMedia]

German Court Decision Hands Big Win to File-Sharers March 20, 2008
"The Federal Constitutional Court in Germany has ruled that the identities of file-sharers must remain private and can no longer be revealed to media companies who accuse them of copyright infringement. In future, only those accused of ‘heavy’ crimes such as murder, child pornography or kidnapping will be revealed.

Germany has some of the toughest copyright laws and it’s thought that as many as 200,000 German file-sharers have had their identities revealed to entertainment and media companies, so that they may be threatened with legal action." [TorrentFreak]

4/30/04

A Comparison Between the Political Executives of France and Germany

France and Germany’s differing constitutions have resulted in their executives holding different emphasis on the role of the president and the prime minister and the power that they hold over the parliament. For example, Germany has a greater separation of powers, where the president is confined to state matters and the prime minister (chancellor) maintaining domestic policy. In France however, the president has significantly greater control, being both Head of State and with the most domestic control. Their relationships between the executive and parliament reflect how the leaders and cabinet are able to act. While both the French President and German Chancellor are able to choose the members of the cabinet, the German Chancellor has less control and has to keep one eye on parliament. Being elected by popular mandate, the French President does not have this problem and has the added influence of being able to choose the prime minister as well. On the other hand, similarities do exist. Both presidents have similar roles as Heads of State and they are looked to as spiritual leaders, or guardians of a national ideal. Constitutional checks can still reign in the French President.

The Fourth Republic of France was held hostage by a leaderless parliament. The executive and the National Assembly’s ability to get bogged down by petty squabbles left it both weak and unrepresentative. For example, in the twelve years of the Fourth Republic there were 25 different governments, as political infighting made it impossible to meter out any stable coalition, with the president spending much of his time trying to hold together the parliament. Wright claims the difficulty in parliament choosing a president meant that “they were seen as the creatures and prisoners of the members of parliament who had elected them and who, when choosing the president, had sought to avoid the election of a strong personality – a man who might prove a danger both to the privileges and prerogatives of parliament and to the republic itself”[1]. For example, it took Rene Cote, the last president of the Fourth Republic thirteen ballots in order to get elected, a waste of time and a battering to any political leader’s prestige. It is also put across that any “presidential power was exercised only so long as it was tolerated by parliament and the government”.[2]

The Weimar government of the 1920s and 1930s was Germany’s first attempt at democracy. There were a great deal of flaws which made it a highly unstable political environment. For example, majorities of opponents frequently combined their votes to remove an incumbent chancellor, creating the instability which eventually paved the way for extremist groups like the Nazis to gain support. In 1934 Hitler similarly took advantage of President von Hindenburg’s death to assert himself as Head of State. Hogwood backs up these claims, asserting that these experiences “served as a warning against the concentration of state power under a single leader.”[3]

The French solution to this political instability was to strengthen the presidency, resulting in an example of ‘semi presidential’ government, in which a “president with some executive powers”[4] works extensively with the prime minister to guide government policy. Hogwood feels that in the Fifth Republic electoral politics “came to be dominated by presidential rather than parliamentary election.”[5] The main reason for this level of control is because the president is directly elected by the people. This gives the leader a personal mandate, as “a direct election confers legitimacy on the president, giving the incumbent a sound basis of office.”[6] This is particularly so as the electoral process requires up to two rounds of elections, until a candidate receives a majority of the vote.

Germany’s constitution drafters were at pains to create both an assertive parliament and an assertive government. Their solution was to create Chancellor Democracy. Unlike France, both the President and the Chancellor are indirectly elected. The president is chosen by Electoral College, whilst the chancellor was picked from a majority coalition in the Bundestag. This is in order to “create a balanced and stable system of government in which the executive could not act arbitrarily as it had during the Third Reich.”[7] Although the chancellor was previously elected in that manner there were a number of important changes. Firstly, it was only possible to remove the chancellor if there was a majority agreeing his successor. What Hogwood describes as a ‘constructive vote of no confidence’ helps to avoid the possibility of a power vacuum. The cap on the German President being only allowed two terms of office has proved to be a leash on any politician from exerting his influence for too long. Similarly, another important development was the “clear demarcation of the executive”,[8] as the president has been confined to a merely ceremonial role as head of state.

Both the French and German President’s roles as Head of State are fairly similar and have had successes, both internationally and domestically. For example, the French and German Presidents have been vocal recently in their opposition to the Iraqi war. Domestically, they have similar success representing some form of ideal of the national spirit.

Wright claims that the French President is the “guardian of national interest, the leader of the nation, the physical embodiment of its traditions and its continuity and the guide to its future actions.” [9] For example, the French President, Jacques Chirac has been very vocal in removing religious clothing in the workplace.

Having to deal with the ghosts of Nazism and the unification of Germany in the 90s the German President has an even more critical task. Hogwood highlights this, claiming that “West German presidents took on the role of the guardian of the country’s conscious and morale, working particularly for the people’s moral rehabilitation from war guilt”.[10] Ironically though, she goes on to point out how this created friction with the East Germans. This is because the East Germans were taught that they were working class, and consequentially they were victims. West Germans’ demands for a similar process is often interpreted as “western triumphalism over the fall of the former GDR”,[11] causing great friction in the country.

The French President has significant control over parliamentary process. He has control over patronage, choosing both the prime minister and the members of the cabinet, effectively controlling the direction of the executive. The President also has powers to dissolve the National Assembly and oversee the calling of referendums. Hogwood feels that “as long as the president had a sympathetic majority in parliament, he could in practice appoint and dismiss parliament.”[12] This is backed up by Wright, who asserts that “prime ministers and ministers have been appointed and dismissed without consultation and prime ministerial advice and objections ignored.”[13] This is because he is elected by the people and does not hold any loyalties to parliament, which enables the president to avoid or break parliamentary deadlock more effectively. On the other hand, the French President still does have constitutional checks. For example, the ability to dissolve the National Assembly is only allowed once a year. Similarly, the constitutional checks which have increasingly been ignored by the presidents could easily be returned at any point from an aggressive parliament. The prime minister merely works for the president, attempting to negotiate his policies with the National Assembly.

The German Chancellor has the constitutional right to “determine the general lines of the government’s policy programme”.[14] Like the French President the German Chancellor is able to choose his cabinet and although he is unable to interfere with the ministers’ departments they can “have the upper hand in this balance of responsibilities, because they can reshuffle the cabinet to get their own way.”[15] Also, the executive can bypass the Bundestag’s scrutiny by using committees and the federal system. However, unlike France, Germany’s executive power comes from lower levels upwards. The chancellor is chosen from the majority coalition of parties, taking into account a wide array of German regions (many political parties are regional), and social and economic differences. He is also most likely to have a more conciliatory and encompassing position to have got elected as prime minister in the first place. As a result, unlike the French President when choosing the cabinet the German Chancellor has to keep one eye on the coalition, as his coalition may fall apart if he upsets even minor parties. Hogwood extends the chancellor’s situation, pointing out that when there are many parties involved in a coalition the chancellor “is more likely to take on the character of a co-ordinator rather than the director of government policy.”[16]

Historical events have resulted in the French and German executives appearing so different. As a result France’s executive is more dynamic, as the president is able to make decisions without the need to appease parliament. Germany’s executive is more considered, with most actions being done with the general support of the Bundestag. Consequentially, whereas France’s President leads government policy, Germany’s Chancellor, despite his great level of control can only merely guide it.

This essay was written by Jonathan McHugh in April 2004


[1] Wright, Vincent The Government And Politics Of France (Hutchinson, 1984) p20-23

[2] Ibid. p22

[3] Hogwood, Patricia; Roberts, Geoffrey European Politics Today: Second Edition (Manchester University Press, 2003) p128

[4] Hogwood, Patricia; Roberts, Geoffrey European Politics Today: Second Edition (Manchester University Press, 2003) p127

[5] Ibid. p132

[6] Ibid. p134

[7] Ibid. p168

[8] Hogwood, Patricia; Roberts, Geoffrey European Politics Today: Second Edition (Manchester University Press, 2003) p127

[9] Wright, Vincent The Government And Politics Of France (Hutchinson, 1984) p28

[10] Hogwood, Patricia; Roberts, Geoffrey European Politics Today: Second Edition (Manchester University Press, 2003) p128

[11] Hogwood, Patricia; Roberts, Geoffrey European Politics Today: Second Edition (Manchester University Press, 2003) p129

[12] Ibid. p132

[13] Wright, Vincent The Government And Politics Of France (Hutchinson, 1984) p28

[14] Hogwood, Patricia; Roberts, Geoffrey European Politics Today: Second Edition (Manchester University Press, 2003) p137

[15] Hogwood, Patricia; Roberts, Geoffrey European Politics Today: Second Edition (Manchester University Press, 2003) p137

[16] Ibid. p141

3/12/04

Germany Politics Notes

Germany
• Apart from Austria, Germany is the only federalist state in the European Union
• Germany’s federal constitution provides for vertical dispersal of power between the federation (Bund) and the sixteen states (Lander).
• Each of these sixteen states have the full outfit of government, such as minister presidents and constitutional courts.
• Individual powers mainly police, education, cultural affairs,
• Germany is a ‘republic of states’ princes (Steffani, 1983), with the minister-presidents as the republican version of the earlier princes of the states.
• Although Berlin holds the headquarters of most political groups and institutions there is still a significant amount of power in Bonn. Also, the Federal Constitutional Court resides in Karlsruhe and the German central bank is located in Frankfurt.
• Germany’s federalism is largely ‘intergovernmental in character’ (Smith, 1986)
• ‘Germany’s federalism leaves little autonomy to its member states’ Schmidt, 2003, p64)
• More to do with rights and vetoes on a national level
• Unlike American model which consist of elected representatives of the states, the Bundesrat is composed of members of the state governments which appoint and recall the deputies.
• Richer states have two thirds control of the Bundesrat, allowing them to block any constitutional change.
• “A wide variety of co-governing forces and veto players can result in time consuming processes of consensus formation and conflict resolution.” (Schmidt, 2003, p4)
• Schmidt argues that despite the great problems involved that it is also part of good governance, through guaranteed stability and predictability as a result of fragmenting power.

These notes were created by Jonathan McHugh in March 2004


Source: Political Institutions In The Federal Republic Of Germany: Manfred Schmidt 2003

1/23/04

Transitions to Democracy Notes

Transitions To Democracy
• Is it inevitable that all states will become democracies?
• What factors affect the form democracy finally takes in a state in transition?
• Is it inevitable that a state having become a democracy will remain one?

In order to deal with whether democracy is inevitable and whether it is permanent we need assess factors such as the transition into democracy, the military, as well as economic and social society.

The historical circumstances for revolution are unique to each country, being generally being controlled by:
• How the previous regime broke down
• The nature and duration of authoritarian rule
• How the ruler gained and maintained his legitimacy
• The confidence and competence of the ruler and opponents

A history of liberalism is an important factor in whether a country remains democratic or not. Ever since the French Revolution of 1789, France has been swaying between the desire for liberalism and representation and a strong leader to rule them. Although the Fifth Republic has appeared to have dealt with these apparent contradictions, the presidents emergency powers have the potential for dictatorship similar to Hitler’s assimilation of Germany in the Night of the Long Knives. The longer any period of liberalism the more it is likely that a coup would be met with violent oppoisition.

Many democracies, are started as a result of dictators slowly introducing liberalisation as a result of:
• During times of success
• A weariness of repression

In times of success dictators consider themselves to be in a position where they are able to encourage limited democracy, assuming they will be supported by the population

In weariness, normally from military defeat this is mainly intended as a token gesture.

However, both cases introduce a new factor to society. For a limited democracy there is a growth in individualism and opposition which may create a legitimacy deficit in the medium and long term, especially when people start questioning the role and legitimacy of the leaders.

Part of this extension of civil liberties is as a result of overconfidence of the dictator. This happened and resulted in the collapse of the Argentine military of 1973, Brazilian generals if 1974 and the Portuguese MFA of 1975 to name but a few.

In general, it is felt that if the dictator voluntarily introduced liberal aspects into society it may become easier to undo than if forced to do so by events, such as Czechoslovakia in the 1960s. However, it is at great cost and may take a considerable deal of repression to do so.


Historically, this is still more dangerous for the regime as it normally catalyses opposition which had been easier to put down previously.


The extent of military intervention is important as to whether or not a society can become and remain democratic.

As O’Donnell and Schmitter put it in Transitions From Authoritarian Rule “once the military has reached a minimal level of professionalism, only a severe rupture within it can open the way to a successful revolution”. If the weariness of repression is because of a war the level of militarism domestically may be lower, especially in an unsuccessful one, as most of the most professional forces are fighting elsewhere. This finally would allow for the potential of revolution or concessions which could permit transition as mentioned earlier.

Looking at the Franco regime the strong military was a factor for the collapse of democracy and his maintaining of power. However, by the time of transformation in the 1970s the armed forces had become merely one of several elements in what Juan Linz has called its “limited pluralism”, allowing democracy to come in and stabilise itself in Spain.

When the armed forces does not care for the authoritarian regime it becomes easier for it to have what O’Donnell and Schmitter described as a “hands off attitude to the transition, by declaring themselves concerned only with protecting their own institutional values of stability and autonomy, as well as public order”. This makes it easier for a democracy to establish itself and become stable.

On the other hand, if its involvement is extensive in society the institutional interests of the military cannot but be affected by emerging civilian authorities who may not be sympathetic to such considerations. This can be very dangerous to any democracy, as it will always raise the spectre of future military uprising.


Any democratic and liberal progress must be matched with economic development, as there needs to develop “complex sets of collective actors” to represent and stabilise various social classes.

One of the greatest problems facing any newly democratised countries is that they are highly vulnerable to the outside world economically. In general most authoritarian countries put controls on contact with the outside world both intellectually and economically. When the economic markets are finally opened up these previously underdeveloped economies have to immediately deal with an increasingly advanced and competitive world market. For example, following the collapse of the Soviet Block output fell dramatically for countries such as Poland and Russia until the mid nineties.

In authoritarian regimes there has been a tendency for civil society to decline as a result of physical and ideological repression, coupled with the fact that any participation would have existed in the state controlled public arena. The longer this occurred for the more dangerous it becomes, as Russia is still in a position where people for generations have been unable and now unused to creating societies and organisations independent of the state.

A weak economic system and civil society, such as experienced by many African countries will always find it difficult to maintain democracy in the threat of possible coups as people would be less likely to resist political change and less likely to succeed.

It is improbable that all societies will become democracies, especially at the same time. Underdeveloped societies will find it difficult to resist military rule just as it becomes harder for despots to maintain control over more complex demanding societies. There will always be events which will allow for small groups to assume control of states as well as groups of people to overthrow despots. It is dependent on how society, the military and the leader deals with these events.

These notes were collected by Jonathan McHugh in January 2004


Bibliography

Guillermo O’Donnell And Philippe Schmitter: Transitions From Authoritarian Rule (The John Hopkins University PressxqWSX, 1986)

Hague, Rod; Harrop, Martin and Breslin, Shaun Comparative Government And Politics: An Introduction (Third Edition) (Macmillan, 1992)

Wright, Vincent The Government And Politics Of France (Hutchinson, 1984)