Showing posts with label Cultures and Organisations. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Cultures and Organisations. Show all posts

10/24/08

EU Parliament Monitor - 24/10/08

MEPs approve new EU trade Commissioner Catherine Ashton (UK)
"The European Parliament voted 538 in favour, 40 against and 63 abstentions in favour of new EU trade Commissioner Catherine Ashton from the UK. Baroness Ashton faced a hearing at the European Parliament on Monday. She has been nominated to replace Peter Mandelson as Trade Commissioner following his appointment to the British government. MEPs questioned Baroness Ashton on the future of the Doha Round, the financial crisis, bilateral trade negotiations - and on her own experience.

Baroness Ashton will be Commissioner until the end of the current Commission's mandate - 31 October 2009." [Europa]

Summary of the hearing of Catherine Ashton (United Kingdom), Commissioner-designate for Trade
"Commissioner-designate Catherine Ashton faced a hearing at the European Parliament on Monday. She has been nominated to replace Peter Mandelson as Trade Commissioner following his appointment to the British government. MEPs questioned Baroness Ashton on the future of the Doha Round, the financial crisis, bilateral trade negotiations - and on her own experience. The outcome will be considered on Tuesday by the Conference of Presidents, with the full Parliament due to vote on Wednesday." [Europa]

Ashton wins emphatic endorsement from MEPs
MEPs back the new trade commissioner; Ashton wants better co-ordination of trade policy.
Members of the European Parliament yesterday (22 October) endorsed the appointment of Catherine Ashton as the European commissioner for trade. MEPs voted 538 in favour, 40 against, with 63 abstentions during their meeting in Strasbourg. From there, Ashton went directly to Geneva for a dinner with Pascal Lamy, the director-general of the World Trade Organization (WTO), to discuss the prospects of reviving the Doha round of world trade talks.
Ashton had told MEPs on Monday evening (20 October), at a scrutiny hearing, that she would be assuring Lamy that “the WTO and pursuing a successful Doha round remain absolutely central to Europe's trade policy”. [EuropeanVoice]

EU parliament formally approves new trade commissioner
"MEPs have formally endorsed the appointment of Catherine Ashton as the EU’s new trade commissioner.
Deputies meeting in Strasbourg on Wednesday voted 538 in favour of her appointment, with 40 against and 63 abstentions. She replaces Peter Mandelson, who stepped down after four years in the job to become the new business secretary in the UK. Ashton faced a hearing in parliament on Monday in which is she is generally thought to have given a good account of her grasp of the notoriously difficult trade portfolio.She was also questioned on the future of the Doha round, the financial crisis and bilateral trade negotiations.

The conference of presidents, or group leaders, endorsed her appointment on Tuesday ahead of today’s vote by the full parliament." [TheParliament]

Alliance of Civilisations: Jorge Sampaio addresses MEPs
"Building bridges and altering misguided perceptions of other cultures are crucial in a globalised world, according Jorge Sampaio, UN High Representative for the Alliance of Civilizations and a former President of Portugal, who addressed a formal sitting of the EP on Wednesday on the subject of cultural diversity, in a speech given as part of the EP's series of guest speeches for Year of Intercultural Dialogue.

In his introduction, the President of the European Parliament, Hans-Gert Pöttering, stressed the shared outlook between the UN Alliance of Civilisations and the EP, with their emphasis on the importance of cultural interaction, and argued that there was a need in the modern world for practical not just symbolic steps on this front, such as the many projects the EP had supported in the context of Year of Intercultural Dialogue.

At the start of his address, Mr Sampaio read out a short statement on behalf of the UN Secretary General, which said that "Like many other regions of the world, Europe faces multiple challenges in promoting intercultural dialogue. Migration, economic uncertainty and political tensions are putting strains on relations between different cultural, ethnic and religious groups. But it is precisely in your region, where constructive contacts over the centuries have allowed humanity to take major leaps forward, that opportunities for reconciliation and cooperation exist." Ultimately, "Cross-cultural tolerance, dialogue, respect and understanding must be pillars of the better world we are trying to build."" [Europa]


Row flares over EU commission's link with business group
"A furious row has flared over allegations of an “intimate” relationship between the commission’s trade directorate and the organisation representing European SMEs. It follows claims by a left-wing Swedish MEP of a possible conflict of interest between the influential directorate and Businesseurope. GUE/NGL member Jens Holm sets out his allegations in a letter to new EU trade commissioner Catherine Ashton.

But Philippe De Buck, director general of Businesseurope, hit back on Thursday, telling this website, “What is the problem?
“Yes, we have a close relationship with DG trade – they need us but, equally, we need them. I make no secret of that.
“However, I want to stress that all dealings between my organisation and the commission are done openly, publicly and transparently, and I object to these comments,” said De Buck, formerly the organisation’s secretary general." [TheParliament]

Click here to read the European Parliament Monitor

9/30/08

EU Public Affairs Monitor - 30/09/08

Symposium Calls For End Of Binary Discussion Of Rightsholders Versus Pirates
"Copyright discussion has become a simplistic binary debate of “pirates that steal everything” versus “rightsholders that want to protect everything,” warned Japanese entrepreneur, blogger and CEO of the Creative Commons Joichi Ito in his opening remarks for this year’s Ars Electronica Symposium in Linz, Austria.

Ito was curator of the symposium on the “New Cultural Economy” that sought to get beyond the simplistic dichotomy and explore ideas and status of alternative content production and social action using digital networks." [IPWatch]

7/14/06

Hofstede’s Analytical Framework

The backbone of Hofstede’s work is that culture mentally programs everybody, both consciously and unconsciously, with society forming peoples values as a result of symbols (words, gestures, pictures, or objects), heroes (people living or not highly prized in a culture) and rituals (unnecessary collective activities carried out for their own sake. Presented in the form of an “Onion” (below), which shows the interrelationship and the steps that form values and how each group is visible (the furthest away from the centre).


From research in the 1970s on cross cultural differences among IBM’s global network of employees Hofstede developed his five dimensions of High vs Low Power Distance, Individualism vs Collectivism, Masculinity vs Feminism, High vs Low Uncertainty and Long vs Short Term orientation in order to help differentiate national characteristics.

High vs Low Power Distance

Country Score Rank

France 68 27 – 29

Belgium Walloon 67 30 – 31

Belgium Flemish 61 39 - 40

Spain 56 45 – 46

Netherlands 38 61

Germany 35 63 – 65

Great Britain 35 63 - 65

The dimension of High vs Low Power Distance has been able to differentiate between countries desire for either highly regarded figures, whether private, public or communal or the ability to question authority and expect more from them.

Individualism vs Collectivism

Country Score Rank

Great Britain 89 3

Netherlands 80 4 – 6

Belgium Flemish 78 8

Belgium Walloon 72 12

France 71 13 – 14

Germany 67 18

Spain 51 30

Individualism vs Collectivism highlights how people and groupings prioritize themselves, with individualist countries favouring personal ambition, whereas collectivists put a greater emphasis on group priority. This enables analysis as to why America is more individualist compared to Japan and offer ways to deal with this.

Masculinity vs Feminity

Country Score Rank

Germany 66 11 – 13

Great Britain 66 11 – 13

Belgian Walloon 60 21

Belgian Flemish 43 47 – 50

France 43 47 – 50

Netherlands 14 72

Masculinity is described as a method of achieving results no matter what the costs, whereas Femininity is the belief in allowing other things to be prioritized in society than material gain. With this tool the book was able to detail why masculine countries such as the USA had such an aggressive form of capitalism and countries such as Sweden prefer a more caring welfare state.

High vs Low Uncertainty

Country Score Rank

Belgian Flemish 97 5

Belgian Walloon 93 9 – 10

France 86 17 -22

Spain 86 17 -22

Germany 65 43

Netherlands 53 53

Great Britain 35 66 -67

High verses Low uncertainty countries responses to events and groups of people were considered to be highly different as a result of differing needs for stability and fear of unknown groups or events. Hofestede’s analysis was used to justify situations such as why it may have been possible for racism in Germany in the 1930s and a low amount of laws in relaxed countries such as Australia.

Short vs Long Term Orientation

Country Score Rank

Netherlands 44 13 -14

France 39 19

Belgium total 38 20 – 21

Germany 31 25 – 27

Great Britain 25 32 – 33

Spain 19 35 – 36

The fifth dimension, Short vs Long Term Orientation describes how and why some cultures have their eye on the future, such as China, whereas countries such as the United States are very much focused on the now. This assumption is used to justify policies ranging from why Americans do not save enough to factors underlining what people desire from relationships.

Extracted and summarised by Jonathan McHugh in July 2006 from:

Cultures and Organizations: Software of the Mind

Geert Hofstede and Gert Jan Hofstede

McGraw-Hill 2005

4/2/06

Book Review of Cultures and Organizations: Software of the Mind.

Authors: Geert and Gert Jan Hofstede 2005 McGraw Hill

Geert and Gert Hofstede’s revised book, Cultures and Organizations: Software of the Mind contains three different approaches to understanding cultures and management throughout the world and thus need to be examined separately. The first reintroduces and builds upon Geert’s work in the 1970s on cross cultural differences among IBM’s global network of employees using his five dimensions of High vs Low Power Distance, Individualism vs Collectivism, Masculinity vs Feminism, High vs Low Uncertainty and Long vs Short Term orientation in order to help differentiate national characteristics. Part Two is an attempt to create a similar language for different business cultures in organizations. This is done through documenting similar methods to Geert’s IBM research, measuring the differences between employees within an organization, differing company goals and attempting to show how nationality can influence the value held. Part Three is intended to be a practical guide for recognizing and dealing with cultural differences and shocks and advice for differing groups to use, such as multinationals, politicians, media groups and parents. Its methodology, particularly in the first half of the book is to start from a statistical framework for highlighting differences and then justifying it with real world experience and academic research. This is where its success lies. However, as the book develops it becomes too general and as a consequence holds less authority, as it becomes less scientific, too broad and more effectively covered by other textbooks.

Introductionary Section

The backbone of Hofstedes’ book is that culture mentally programs everybody, both consciously and unconsciously, with society forming peoples values as a result of symbols (words, gestures, pictures, or objects), heroes (people living or not highly prized in a culture) and rituals (unnecessary collective activities carried out for their own sake. Presented in the form of an “Onion” (below), which shows the interrelationship and the steps that form values and how each group is visible (the furthest away from the centre).

Target Diagram


Geert’s work considers this to be self replicating, with one generation passing down its fundamental beliefs, which although slightly changing as a result of individual personality and contemporary developments in the world will still continue.

This notion is even stretched into the context of social Darwinism, with a belief that differing cultural patterns exists for different groups of apes and chimpanzees. The differing forces put on man, it is explained forced man to live with differing values to others, as climate and differing challenges forced communities across the world to employ different priorities in order to be more successful. Gradually developing throughout the periods of man, Darwinism sits comfortably with Hoftedes’ cultural reasons as to why some people took on certain characteristics, even explaining why some races disappeared, declined in influence and why there were some major events in history, such as the reformation. This is obviously creates a form of analytical bias, which forms a more of an social evolutionary framework than political, economic or even religious (often too heavily criticized, possibly from a scientific bias) analysis of world events and development.

The attempts to highlight the methods of research draw an interesting insight into the process of analysis. The procedure of validating, i.e. drawing assumptions from the real world in order to justify statistics can be dangerous, as it can result in people seeing validation everywhere, despite having misleading information. However, the text is well research is well balanced, with views from Europe (particularly French), S.E Asia (particularly China) and America clearly represented and balanced satisfactorily.

Part One: Dimensions of National Cultures

Geert Hofstead’s research into IBM employees from around the world was an attempt to understand the differing values that people hold and to create some language or tools for understanding why this exists and how this can effect future actions. The aforementioned dimensions of High vs Low Power Distance, Individualism vs Collectivism, Masculinity vs Feminism, High vs Low Uncertainty and Long vs Short Term provide highly interesting conclusions to different thinking patterns.

The dimension of High vs Low Power Distance has been able to differentiate between countries desire for either highly regarded figures, whether private, public or communal or the ability to question authority and expect more from them. This method was able to differentiate between groups of countries, such as the Scandinavian block, which favored a more democratic process and more authoritarian countries such as China, which preferred leaders to exercise more authority

Individualism vs Collectivism highlights how people and groupings prioritize themselves, with individualist countries favoring personal ambition, whereas collectivists put a greater emphasis on group priority. This enables analysis as to why America is more individualist compared to Japan and offer ways to deal with this.

Masculinity is described as a method of achieving results no matter what the costs, whereas Femininity is the belief in allowing other things to be prioritized in society than material gain. With this tool the book was able to detail why masculine countries such as the USA had such an aggressive form of capitalism and countries such as Sweden prefer a more caring welfare state.

High verses Low uncertainty countries responses to events and groups of people were considered to be highly different as a result of differing needs for stability and fear of unknown groups or events. The data collection was used to justify why it may have been possible for racism in Germany in the 1930s and a low amount of laws in relaxed countries such as Australia.

The fifth dimension, Short vs Long Term Orientation describes how and why some cultures have their eye on the future, such as China, whereas countries such as the United States are very much focused on the now. This assumption is used to justify policies ranging from why Americans do not save enough to factors underlining what people desire from relationships.

The success of this strain of analysis is to highlight not only differences more obvious between continental cultures but also subsets, highlighting differences between (for example) North European and Southern European as a result of different climates, resources, history forming habits. As a result conclusions as to the similarities between Austria and Germany and Spain and Portugal both using statistics of IBMs employees and analysis appears highly insightful.

The method of analysis using validation from an evolutionary perspective has been very well used. However, many assumptions, although appearing correct become misleading after detailed analysis. For example, bracketing the growth of Protestantism in England and Germany together as a cultural movement is misleading, as it was politically top down (ie Henry VIII) in England and bottom up (as a result of the Gettysburg Press). So much emphasis is put on culture by the authors that it forgets that there are moments in history where cultures are formed as a result of institutions (such as the growth of English Protestantism) or from major events that cause shifts in cultures (although briefly mentioned more could have been made on the potential effects of the September 11th attacks on America’s uncertainty avoidance for example.

Part Two: Cultures in Organizations

Satisfied by the analysis of why different cultures have alternative beliefs and habits, Part Two attempts to do the same in terms of work culture and management. However, its emphasis on summarizing other works and integrating them into the authors’ own viewpoint shows a lack of confidence and less of a coherent method of cutting across the thinking and processes of individual companies than in Part One.

Highlighting works such as Mintzberg’s Cultural and Organizational Structure help to understand organizations, such as the five configurations (The Simple Structure, The Machine Bureaucracy, The Professional Bureaucracy, The Divisionalized Form and the Adhocracy). This can help highlight how an organization coordinates, standardizes and monitors processes. Again, there is felt to be some sort of correlation between his conclusions and that of the IBM inter country research, with the idea that certain countries would hold preferences for certain structures, such as the United States preferring the Divisionized form and France the Bureaucracy as a result of certain cultural preferences.

Similarly, the summary of the different Corporate Goals of national companies similarly offers an interesting look as to how companies govern themselves. The rankings of the six greatest priorities of businessmen also seem to correlate well with Geert Hofstede’s Five Dimensions Theory.

Hofstedes’ conclusions over risk and accountancy practices seem to fit rather well, with differences in Power Distances and Uncertainty enabling for a suitable point of discussion for differing accounting practices. The notion of symbols is also used well as a tool to differentiate the differences in the value of money and the conventions held between bankers and accountants.

In their analysis, Geert and Gert Jan reference American management theories very rarely. Whilst discussing leadership and motivation they feel the need to mention it but as European academics are keen to distance themselves, with only one American quotation in the whole text. Their cynicism is seen when highlighting the situations which enable American models to be successful but also showing how the differences that exist between countries (as shown in the 5 dimensions) highlight a poor fit of cultural styles. Later they back this up, citing the failure of organizational culture theories when adapted to France. This is well reasoned, with their philosophy of cultural inclusiveness giving clues but beneficially offering no concrete answers, in order to foster personal customization, suggesting that there is no single formula for developing successful managers that can be used in all cultures.

The more original research into organizational cultures find six dimensions, namely Handling People vs Handling Things (comparing the roles or nurses and engineers in who or what they deal with); Specialist vs Generalist (a psychologist would be more specialist than a politician, say); Disciplined vs Independent (a police officer would have less discretion than a shopkeeper); Structured vs Unstructured (a systems analyst would have more of a defined role than a fashion designer); Theoretical vs Practical (a professor would be more academic than a salesman) and Formative vs Pragmatic (where procedures were more important than results, such as in the public sector).

This is built upon when these results were used to distinguish between Elephants, slow bulky but self confident companies and Storks, reliable, caring and transporting companies. Subcultures are more easily understood when tied in with further theories on Alienation, Commitment to work, a personal need for achievement, personal masculinity, orderliness and authoritarianism.

Similar to Geert Hofstead’s 5 dimensions of national cultures the 6 dimensions of organizations are non discriminatory, merely being tools to analyze the differences between companies and possibly help judge the possible suitability. Although useful as a result of not focusing entirely on cultural issues the topic feels like a shoe-in of new management theories into Geert Hofstede’s cultural dynamics philosophy covered in Part One. As a result the theory is useful, although not revolutionary.

Part Three: Implications

The third part offers a range of situations, such as diplomacy or in business, which helps to highlight flaws in cross cultural misunderstanding. For example, dangers to international mergers and acquisitions have been highlighted in situations such recognizing both areas for at least an interim period and the necessity of charasmatic leadership

Problems of culture shock are summarized well in the Acculturation Curve (below), which summarize a tourist or expatriate worker over time. This is divided into Euphoria (A), the positive experience of finding something new, Culture Shock (B) the readjusting to new norms, Acculturation (C), the coming to terms with a new environment and A Stable Set (D), where the experience settles and is either positive, neutral or negative.

Time

The book suggests that failures from cultural shocks are overestimated, with statistics quoted usually being echoed from unreliable sources. It also appears correct in addressing that problems that do occur and suggests useful methods to limit this. In the case of businesses the advice of forcing expats to integrate more and give them adequate cultural teaching (if language training is too difficult given the time) is helpful but not too illuminating.

Conclusion

This book is an interesting and broad introduction to the challenges of organization and individuals dealing with other beliefs and processes. The development of cross cultural understanding using the language of Hofstede’s five dimensions mentioned in Part One can be a highly powerful tool for analysis. The management advice in Part Two for looking at organizations and comparing is useful, although not revolutionary. Similarly, the Third Part creates a useful insight into the challenges created from dealing with other cultures, although it is not as distinct as the advice offered in other texts. Ultimately the three part approach to cross culture is interesting but flawed. The quality of writing at the beginning was so much more thought out than the final two parts that the authors would have benefited from more of an integration of ideas or treated as three separate topics in different books.


This review was written by Jonathan McHugh in April 2006

1/11/06

The Differences In Between Multinationals and International Companies

Clear differences in cultures around the world create challenges for human resource management, particularly companies which operate in radically different countries. Global companies have tended to choose between two main philosophies in business, the multinational, localised method for human resource management and the international method, which is more centralised. Each of them have their own distinct strengths and advantages, with the most effective option being dependent on the breadth of cultural differences in the company and the tasks and relationships of workers (both between each other and with their employer).

Globalisation
Globalisation has extended international business’s scope, from merely exchanging goods between companies and organisations between borders to corporations which have many physical operations and services in many countries of the world. Geography is no longer as important factor to these global companies, who are able to move their resources across continents.

Culture
However, despite the relative ease of transferring factors of production or capital to other countries cultural differences distinct effects as a result of different norms and values are still significant and crucial for high levels of profit. Differences are especially more pronounced between western and eastern countries. For example, Japanese employees are highly collective (work as a team and have huge respect for authority (high power distance). On the other hand, an American employee is highly individualistic (values themselves over their team) and have a low power distance (as they feel entitled to challenge authority figures and possibly ridicule). This creates challenges for human resources and a number of solutions

Multinational Method: The Local Approach
For multinational companies there is a priority of using local strengths and characteristics and ensuring that they are employed with the company’s global vision.. This hands-off method is often used by companies who accept these differences between their home country and their foreign subsidiary. In such a situation the affiliates would have significant local authority in human resource policies such as recruitment and remuneration. In this case only human resources control from headquarters would be financial.

Often this is because it is considered that there are specific benefits as a result, such as bridging cultural differences within the organisation. In these cases there are felt to be more benefits to build on what employees know and are comfortable with as a result of cultural conditioning than to force them to change their natural viewpoint and structure. This method allows the affiliates to concentrate more on their clients more effectively, allowing them to be highly responsive to movements in the markets. This method tends to get used more in situations where social cultural diversity is more significant than technical and product operation as these reflect cultural norms more easily. Equality of the recruitment in the developing world is going to be highly important in the future. The developing worlds labour force is no longer cheap labour but highly skilled, especially given the lower wages. Because of the more positive emphasis put on local customs and experience it is much easier for multinational companies to recognise the benefit of local knowledge compared to hiring expensive expat employees to perform the same task.

However, if business and human resource policy is too focused on local trends this results in the subsidiary following the principle goals of the parent company. As a result the decentralised company fails to improve international coordination in projects, one of the main benefits of global business. Also, the possible benefits that made the parent company so successful initially may be mistranslated by the subsidiary offshoots in other countries with not enough centralisation.

International Method: The Global Approach
International companies have a unified approach to business which extends to human resource systems. They have more centralised processes, such as recruitment remuneration and promotion as the perceived wisdom on managerial theory was so successful in the parent company (and possibly other countries) that its values should be exported despite possible costs in restructuring and reducing local flexibility.

This method is particularly useful in more technical procedures and product operation as these methods can usually be introduced with little disruption to what the workers are used to. For example, cultural factors make less impact on decisions to introduce more western processes in a Chinese factory than in a Chinese computer software company.

On the other hand, the assumption that a company’s philosophies are so great that they can be exported everywhere can create a level of arrogance that is easily observable in human resources. These tend to be highly expensive as a result of expecting lots of perks to match their previous earnings in another country and it is difficult to encourage them to stay with the company when they return home as they become used to their levels of responsibility abroad. The over reliance of expats to implement policy in other countries creates a bias and makes companies undervalue the potential labour that they already employ locally. This can have significant effects on morale in the workforce if it becomes clear to some workers that they will be overlooked for promotion, not to mention that the more qualified employee may be overlooked. However, these cultural biases are decreasing over time.

Conclusion
There are significant differences between multinational and international companies and is highly important for international human resource managers to consider. Levels of cultural differences between the countries involved and the tasks required result in careful examination of the benefits and costs. However, both policies’ strengths and weaknesses are slowly being utilised in future international business structures, as some countries are becoming so large that they will be able to shed the skins of nationality and cultural preferences. However, until then businessmen and human resource managers will have to find some compromise.

This report was written by Jonathan McHugh in January 2006